Simon chuckled at the song choice, thinking it was a joke, until the first note left him stunned with instant regret

Josh Krajcik’s 2011 audition on The X Factor remains unforgettable. The humble Ohio burrito maker stepped onstage with a cheerful, carefree vibe, surprising the audience with his choice of At Last by Etta James. Skepticism filled the air, especially from Simon Cowell, notorious for questioning bold song choices.

But the moment Josh began to sing, the room transformed. His rich, soulful voice carried raw emotion and power, silencing any doubts. The audience erupted, and the judges, visibly moved, unanimously sent him through. His journey didn’t end there—Josh went on to become the season’s runner-up, leaving a lasting legacy as one of the show’s most iconic contestants.

Josh’s performance is a testament to the magic of true talent emerging from unexpected places. His heartfelt rendition of At Last was more than a song—it was pure, unfiltered passion, reminding us all of the power of music to inspire and connect.