This Just Doesnt Look like Her, How This 90s Star Has Changed over the Years

Once celebrated as the quintessential ’90s girl-next-door, this Hollywood star has undergone a striking transformation that has captured the attention of social media users. Renowned for her timeless beauty and iconic roles, she has recently sparked debate among fans who claim she “doesn’t even look like the same person” anymore.

The actress first stole hearts in the ’90s as Sarah Reeves Merrin on Party of Five, embodying a heartfelt and complex character that resonated deeply with viewers.

At the ABC Television Affiliates Party on June 9, 1994, in Century City, California. | Source: Getty Images

Shortly thereafter, she made a splash on the big screen with I Know What You Did Last Summer, where her portrayal of a terrified teenager solidified her place in the thriller genre.

Her meteoric rise to fame quickly established her as a cultural icon of the ’90s, accompanied by a signature look that perfectly captured the era’s aesthetic.

At the 125th Edition of the Ringling Bros. and Barnum & Bailey Circus Opening Night Performance on April 27, 1995, in Los Angeles, California. | Source: Getty Images

With her expressive brown eyes and warm smile, she exuded relatability and magnetism. Her style, characterized by classic ’90s staples like fitted crop tops, denim jackets, and minimalist dresses, perfectly encapsulated the wholesome girl-next-door image.

During the 1995 MTV’s Rock n’ Jock Basketball event in Los Angeles, California. | Source: Getty Images

However, as her career flourished, media attention increasingly shifted from her acting talent to her physical appearance. Interviews from that time reveal a troubling emphasis on her body.

Questions directed at her often crossed the line into inappropriate territory, reflecting an unsettling reality of how young actresses were routinely objectified.

At the “Three Wishes” premiere on October 24, 1995, in Beverly Hills, California. | Source: Getty Images

Reflecting on this period, she noted, “At the time, when interviewers were asking what would now be considered incredibly inappropriate questions, it didn’t feel that way.” She explained, “I was in barely any clothing the whole movie, so I thought, ‘I guess they wouldn’t be asking if it were inappropriate.'”

Despite striving for authenticity and depth in her roles, the actress found herself frequently relegated to conversations focused solely on her appearance.

“In Heartbreakers, I was disappointed that the discussion revolved around body image because I had worked hard in that movie to deliver a strong performance,” she admitted. “I wished that for just five minutes, the conversation had been about my acting rather than comments on my body.”

The actress in 1995. | Source: Getty Images

Recognizing the shift in focus from her talent to her looks, she took a stand by wearing a T-shirt emblazoned with “Silicone Free,” challenging the invasive nature of media inquiries.

At the premiere of That Thing You Do on September 30, 1996, in Los Angeles, California. | Source: Getty Images

Years later, she expressed regret over how she had brushed off such objectification in her youth. “Now that I’m older, I think, ‘I wish I had understood how inappropriate that was so I could have defended myself or not answered those questions.’ I often laughed it off, and I wish I hadn’t,” she reflected.

The actress at the Fashion Café in New York in 1996. | Source: Getty Images

Motherhood marked a pivotal turning point in her life, reshaping her perspective on both her body and her career.

After giving birth to her first child and dealing with post-pregnancy weight gain, she candidly admitted, “Having spent 25 years thinking about my appearance, it was challenging when the weight didn’t come off as quickly as I had hoped.”

At the “House Arrest” premiere on July 20, 1996, in Westwood, California. | Source: Getty Images

Ultimately, she embraced the reality of her changing body, prioritizing her daughter’s well-being over regaining her pre-baby figure. “I asked myself, ‘Would I want her to feel this way when she grows up?’ I realized I needed to change my mindset,” she said.

At the Back to School fashion show on August 17, 1996, in Miami, Florida. | Source: Getty Images

This newfound perspective continued as she shared a heartfelt message with her followers on her 44th birthday in 2023. Reflecting on the aging process, she expressed feelings of “gratefulness, blessing, happiness, and occasional insecurities about growing older.”

Later that year, during an appearance on the “Inside of You” podcast, she candidly shared, “I don’t want to say that aging is hard because it’s a privilege.”

During an interview with Jay Leno on October 22, 1996. | Source: Getty Images

She continued, “Aging means you’re here, still living, and every line represents a smile or laugh you’ve had… But aging in Hollywood can be incredibly challenging. You can’t seem to do anything right.”

At the 23rd Annual American Music Awards in 1996 in Los Angeles, California. | Source: Getty Images

This beloved actress is none other than Jennifer Love Hewitt, now 45. Her transformation over the years has sparked conversations about her appearance, leaving some fans convinced she looks like a different person compared to the star they once adored.

At the 65th Annual Hollywood Christmas Parade on December 1, 1996, in Hollywood, California. | Source: Getty Images

1994 – 1999
In 1994, Hewitt showcased a fresh, youthful look that highlighted her natural charm. Her long, straight hair and minimal makeup complemented her radiant girl-next-door appeal.

Jennifer Love Hewitt circa 1994.

By 1999, Hewitt’s look evolved, reflecting her transition from a teen star to an established figure in Hollywood.

At the First Annual Teen Choice Awards on August 1, 1999, in Santa Monica, California.

2001 – 2004
In 2001, Hewitt radiated youthful glamour with her voluminous shoulder-length curls and warm smile. This period highlighted her playful side, showcasing an effortless elegance that was vibrant and inviting.

At the 10th Annual Boathouse Rock Dance Party on June 11, 2001, in New York.

By 2004, her style took on a more refined tone, as she wore her hair sleek with straight bangs, enhancing her sophistication.

During the ShoWest 2004 Fox Searchlight Pictures event on March 25, 2004, in Las Vegas, Nevada.

2006 – 2008
In 2006, Hewitt embraced a glamorous look, sporting voluminous waves and a radiant smile that underscored her timeless appeal. Her makeup emphasized her expressive eyes, enhancing her natural elegance and star quality.

Arriving at “The Envelope Please” Oscar viewing party on March 5, 2006, in West Hollywood, California.

By 2008, her style shifted towards a more understated elegance, with sleek, sophisticated hair that showcased her maturity.

At the Step Up Women’s Network 2008 Inspiration Awards Luncheon on May 9, 2008, in Beverly Hills, California.

2010 – 2013
In 2010, Hewitt combined glamour with a hint of natural charm, styling her hair in a loose, voluminous updo that showcased her radiant smile and bright eyes.

At the Oceana benefit at Esquire House LA on November 13, 2010, in Los Angeles, California.

In 2013, her look reflected a graceful acceptance of aging, featuring loose waves and minimal makeup that highlighted her evolving beauty.

Photographed in Los Angeles, California, on September 13, 2013.

2015 – 2019
In 2015, Hewitt exuded elegance with a subtle glow that accentuated her timeless beauty. Her refined look conveyed confidence and sophistication as she embraced new chapters in her life and career.

Filming “Criminal Minds” in 2015.

By 2018, she maintained her youthful charm with a warm smile and flowing waves that captured her approachable appeal. Her style balanced classic Hollywood glamour with modern sensibilities.